William Rowley was one of the most prolific playwright-collaborators of the Jacobean period, co-authoring plays with John Day, George Wilkins, Thomas Heywood, John Fletcher, John Webster, Thomas Dekker, Thomas Middleton, and possibly even William Shakespeare, although this last collaboration is widely contested. Gerard Langbaine (1656-1692) famously recounted Rowley’s intimate relationship with the prime poets of the age
: He was not only beloved by those Great Men, Shakespear, Fletcher, and Johnson; but likewise writ with the former, The Birth of Merlin
([Langbaine 428](BIBL1.xml#LANG23)). However, Shakespeare’s contribution to this play has been ruled out by the evidence of records produced by Sir Henry Herbert, Master of the Revels, licensing the play under its alternate title
The Child hath Founde his Fathe. He calls it a
New Play, acted by the
Princes Servants at the Curtayne
,
1622 (Gunby qtd. in
[Bawcutt 136](BIBL1.xml#BAWC1)).
Shakespeare died in
1616. The true contributor remains unknown at this time.
Rowley produced four plays without collaborators:
A Shoemaker, a Gentleman (c.
1608),
A New Wonder, A Woman Never Vexed (c.
1610),
All’s Lost by Lust (c.
1619), and
A Match at Midnight (c.
1622-1623).
Langbaine relates the following about the plot of
A New Wonder in his
Account of the English Dramatick Poets:
That passage of the Widows finding her Wedding-Ring, which she dropp’d in crossing the [Thames](THAM2.xml), in the Belly of Fish which her Maid bought accidentally in the Market, is founded either upon the Story of Polycrates of Samos, as the Author may read at large in Herodotus, Lib. 3. five Thalia; or upon the like Story related of one Anderson of Newcastle, by Doctor Fuller, in his Worthies of England.
[Langbaine 429](BIBL1.xml#LANG23)
Rowley’s name first appeared in 1607 as co-author of a mediocre adventure play,
The Travels of the Three English Brothers (
[Holdsworth xii](BIBL1.xml#HOLD5)), which he wrote with
Day and
Wilkins. Our first record of
Rowley as an actor is a
1609 costume purchase, made by
five leading Duke of York’s men from John Heminges
(
1566-1630) (
[Gunby](BIBL1.xml#GUNB2);
[Bentley 555-556](BIBL1.xml#BENT1)). He seems to have made his career primarily as an actor. As a member of the
Duke of York’s Company—which formed in
1608 but was not licensed to perform in
[London](LOND5.xml) until
1610—
Rowley was acting in their daily performances by
1609 (outside of
[London](LOND5.xml)), and handling much of their business (
[Chambers 242](BIBL1.xml#CHAM1)). A player of increasing importance,
Rowley was leader of the company by
1616 (
[Holdsworth xii](BIBL1.xml#HOLD5)). The company was first called the
Duke of York’s Men and later named
Prince Charles’ Men, or simply the
Prince’s Men (the exact date of this renaming is uncertain). For the last two or three years of his life, however,
Rowley was a member of the
King’s Men (
[Bentley 555](BIBL1.xml#BENT1)). He most likely joined by
1623, when he is listed as cast member in
The Maid of the Mill, which was licensed for the
King’s Men by the Master of the Revels on
22 August 1623 (
[Bawcutt xxii](BIBL1.xml#BAWC1)). However, one point of contention is that he attended
James I’s funeral in the livery of the
Prince’s Men (wearing black cloth), which was held on
7 May 1625 (
[Bawcutt xxiii](BIBL1.xml#BAWC1)). Bentley has suggested that he was not yet sworn in as a member of the
King’s Men, and was thus included as part of his former company rather than being omitted from the ceremony altogether. He appears four times on the lists of the
King’s Men before his death in
1626 (
[Bentley 556](BIBL1.xml#BENT1)). It may also be possible that he was earlier a member of
Queen Anne’s Men owing to some collaborations licensed under that company of players (
[Gunby 1-6](BIBL1.xml#GUNB2)).
At various times and by numerous scholars, Rowley has been reported as colloborater, part-author, or reviser of over 50 works ([Holdsworth xii](BIBL1.xml#HOLD5)). The following are the plays most commonly attributed to him (Robb qtd. in [Bawcutt xxiv](BIBL1.xml#BAWC1)):
- The Travels of the Three English Brothers (1607) (with Day and Wilkins)
- A Shoemaker, a Gentleman (c. 1608)
- Fortune by Land and Sea (c. 1608-1609) (with Heywood)
- A New Wonder, a Woman Never Vexed (c. 1610)
- The Old Law (c. 1615) (with Middleton and Massinger)
- A Fair Quarrel (1615-1616) (with Middleton)
- All’s Lost by Lust (c. 1619)
- The World Tossed at Tennis (early 1620) (with Middleton)
- The Birth of Merlin (c. 1620) (collaborator uncertain)
- The Witch of Edmonton (1621) (with Dekker and Ford)
- The Changeling (1622) (with Middleton)
- A Match at Midnight (c. 1622-1623)
- The Spanish Gipsie (1623) (with Middleton)
- The Maid in the Mill (1623) (with Fletcher)
- A Cure for the Cuckold (1625) (with Webster)
However, in his biographical essay in the
Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Gunby disputes the dates of
The Old Law (
1618, not
1615),
A Fair Quarrel (
1617, not
1615-1616), and
The World Tossed at Tennis (
1622 specifically, not early
1620), and also asserts that
Massinger’s contribution to
The Old Law is minimal at best, and highly contested. Another of
Rowley’s plays entitled
Hymen’s Holiday, or Cupid’s Vagaries, has not survived, but was reportedly performed at court on
24 February 1612 (
[Chambers 3.473](BIBL1.xml#CHAM1);
[Bawcutt xxii](BIBL1.xml#BAWC1)).
Rowley’s non-dramatic works include an elegy on the death of fellow Prince’s Men company member Hugh Atwell (1621), another elegy for Prince Henry (1612), and a prose pamphlet,
A Search for Money (
1609) (
[Bawcutt xxiii-xxiv](BIBL1.xml#BAWC1)). Gunby notes that
[h]e also contributed commendatory verses to John Taylor’s Nipping or Snipping of Abuses (1614) and to the 1623 quarto of Webster’s The Duchess of Malfi
(
[Gunby 1-6](BIBL1.xml#GUNB2)).
Rowley was best known for his fat clown roles, which he seems to have mastered both in writing and performance, suggesting he was likely a man of large physical stature. His character in Middleton’s
Inner Temple Masque (c.
1619),
Plumporridge, is said to have moved
like one of the great porridge-tubs going to the counter
(qtd in
[Bentley 556](BIBL1.xml#BENT1)). He also played a clown in his own
All’s Lost by Lust (
1619) and a fat bishop in
Middleton’s
A Game at Chess (
1624). He appeared in the following full-figured roles:
- Bustopha in The Maid in the Mill (by Fletcher and Rowley, c. 1623, the King’s Men)
- Tony in A Wife for a Month (by Fletcher, c. 1624, the King’s Men)
- the Cook in the original cast of Rollo or The Bloody Brother (by Fletcher, Jonson, Massinger, and Chapman, c. 1612-1624)
- Cacafogo in Rule a Wife and Have a Wife (by Fletcher, c. 1624, the King’s Men)
- the Clown in The Fair Maid of the Inn (by unknown, c. 1626, the King’s Men) (
[Bentley 556](BIBL1.xml#BENT1))
- Simplicity in The World Tossed at Tennis (by Rowley and Middleton, c. 1620, the King’s Men)
- Chough in A Fair Quarrel (by Rowley and Middleton, c. 1615-1616, the King’s Men) (
[Holdsworth xii](BIBL1.xml#HOLD5))
One of his most celebrated collaborations,
The Changeling (
1622), co-authored with
Middleton, offers a fine example of his talent at writing clown characters, in the portrayal of
Lollio (
[Daalder xii](BIBL1.xml#DAAL1)).
Rowley was most likely the householder buried in February 1625/1626 ([Bentley 556](BIBL1.xml#BENT1)), for on 16 February 1625/1626 Grace, relict (I.e., widow) of William Rowley, appeared before a public notary and renounced administration of his estate ([Bawcutt xxiii](BIBL1.xml#BAWC1)). He is remembered as a collaborator of some of the finest works of the period, but has been largely devalued by critics who champion the isolated genius of the true poet, a romantic notion that is becoming increasingly outdated ([Daalder xxiii](BIBL1.xml#DAAL1)). As academics grow to appreciate collaborators and co-authored texts for their literary value, figures like William Rowley will likely begin to receive the attention they deserve.